Negligence is the core of 1L Torts. You know the four elements. The problem is writing them in a clean order under a clock, with a rule sentence for each one and the facts doing the work. Here is the order to follow, element by element.
Start with duty
Open with the general rule: everyone owes a duty to act as a reasonable person would under the same circumstances. Then ask whether this plaintiff was owed that duty.
This is where Palsgraf comes in. The majority rule follows Cardozo: a defendant owes a duty only to foreseeable plaintiffs, the people within the zone of danger. The minority rule follows Andrews: a defendant owes a duty to anyone injured as a result of the breach, and foreseeability is handled later under proximate cause. If your facts have an unexpected plaintiff, state the majority rule, apply it, then give the Andrews view in one or two sentences.
Watch for special duty facts too: a landowner and an entrant, a rescuer, or a special relationship. Name the duty rule that fits and move on.
Then breach
Breach asks whether the defendant fell below the standard of care. State the reasonable person standard and compare it to what the defendant did. Use the facts. If the fact pattern mentions a statute, raise negligence per se. Under the majority rule, violating a statute establishes duty and breach when the plaintiff is in the class the statute protects and the harm is the type it was meant to prevent. The minority rule treats the violation as evidence of negligence only.
If the facts hide how the injury happened, think res ipsa loquitur: the accident does not normally happen without negligence, and the defendant controlled what caused it.
Causation has two parts
Actual cause comes first. Use the but-for test: but for the defendant's conduct, would the injury have happened? When two causes would each have been enough on their own, use the substantial factor test.
Proximate cause comes second. Ask whether the type of harm was a foreseeable result of the breach. Intervening acts belong here. A foreseeable intervening act, such as ordinary medical negligence in treating the injury, does not cut off liability. A highly unusual one can.
Damages
Negligence requires actual harm, such as personal injury or property damage. Nominal damages are not available. One sentence tying the injury in the facts to this element is usually enough, unless the facts raise the eggshell plaintiff rule. Under that rule, the defendant takes the plaintiff as found and is liable for the full injury even if it was worse than expected.
Close with defenses
Defenses usually turn on the plaintiff's own fault. The majority rule is comparative negligence, which reduces the plaintiff's recovery by the plaintiff's share of fault. Most comparative negligence states use the modified form, which bars recovery once the plaintiff's fault reaches a set level. A smaller group uses pure comparative negligence. The minority rule is contributory negligence, which bars any recovery if the plaintiff was at fault at all. State the majority rule, apply it, then note the result under contributory negligence.
Check assumption of risk last. Express assumption comes from an agreement. Implied assumption comes from the plaintiff knowing about a risk and choosing to face it anyway. In most comparative negligence states, implied assumption folds into the comparative fault analysis.
Practice the order before the exam
Write one timed negligence answer this week with your outline closed. Then check it against the order above: duty, breach, actual cause, proximate cause, damages, defenses.
If you want every element and defense on one checklist, the DBCD: Elements of Negligence & Checklists guide has a full negligence attack outline and Palsgraf steps.
For exam day, the 1L Torts Finals Cheat Sheet gives you the attack order for every Torts essay, majority rule first.
Want practice problems? Fairy Tale Torts has six fact patterns with full F-IRAC model answers.
Check your course materials for the rules your exam expects. This post is a study aid, not legal advice.
Chris Zeriah Collins, MSN, MPH, BSN, RN, founder of the Law Frog RN, Esq. Learning Academy